Judgement after Automation: Posthumanist Reflections on Asimov’s Laws of Robotics

Claudio Celis Bueno and Steve Jankowski

University of Amsterdam

Abstract

Contemporary concerns about artificial intelligence often turn on the philosophical question: What is human about judgement? To understand the premise of this popular imaginary, we turn our attention to Isaac Asimov’s Laws of Robotics, a set of laws deployed within his science fiction stories to create narratives about the relationships between humans and machines. Asimov’s laws reflect a shared imaginary regarding the relationship between humans and technology that permeates beyond the realm of science fiction, shaping some of the basic assumptions behind our definitions of politics, humanity, and freedom.

Interpreting the stories Runaround (1942), Risk (1955), The Bicentennial Man (1976), and Foundation and Earth (1986) through Immanuel Kant and Hannah Arendt’s philosophy of judgement, we pinpoint that the philosophical arcs of these stories are written in the tension concerning who (or what) is capable of both determinative and reflective judgement. Then, following theorists who have interpreted Asimov’s “Zeroth Law” through the lens of posthumanism, we argue that Asimov’s laws are constrained by the conception of reflective judgement as being inherently anthropocentric and limited to closed systems. In contrast, we advance the argument that reflective judgement emerges only through distributed and contingent systems — systems that include humans and non-humans.

What should keep our attention then, is not the existential anxiety over an autonomous artificial intelligence that challenges human superiority, but the politics of creating and maintaining technical systems capable of sustaining distributed forms of reflective judgement.

About the Authors:

Claudio Celis Bueno is an Assistant Professor in New Media and Digital Culture at the University of Amsterdam. He is the author of the book The Attention Economy: Labour, Time and Power in Cognitive Capitalism (2016). His research focuses on the relationship between technology, political philosophy, and political economy.

Steve Jankowski is an Assistant Professor in New Media Histories at the University of Amsterdam. He researches digital utopias, interface design, democratic political theory, media history, and the production of digital knowledge. He is also the principal investigator for a policy research project funded by the Wikimedia Foundation.

Website: https://www.textaural.com

ORCID: 0000-0003-4986-7249

Download Article pdf

Published: 2024 – 11 – 25

Issue: Vol 7 (2024)

Section: Yearly Theme

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.

Copyright for articles published in this journal is retained by the authors, with first publication rights granted to the journal. By submitting to this journal, you acknowledge that the work you submit has not been published before.

Articles and any other work submitted to this journal are published under an Attribution / Non-Commercial Creative Commons license; that is, by virtue of their appearance in this open access journal, articles are free to use – with proper attribution – in educational and other non-commercial settings.

There are no fees for authors publishing in the Journal.