Moreau’s Law in “The Island of Doctor Moreau” in Light of Kant’s Reciprocity Thesis

Moreau’s Law in The Island of Doctor Moreau in Light of Kant’s Reciprocity Thesis

Dan Paul Dal Monte

Temple University

Keywords: free will, Kant, Wells, Moreau, reciprocity thesis, law

Abstract

In this paper, I explore a tension between the Law in the novel The Island of Doctor Moreau, by H. G. Wells, and Kant’s reciprocity thesis. The Law is a series of prohibitions that Moreau has his beasts recite. Moreau devotes his time to transforming animals through a painful surgery into beings that resemble humans, but the humanized beasts are constantly slipping back into animalistic habits, and so Moreau promulgates the Law to maintain decorum. Kant’s reciprocity thesis states that free will is the necessary and sufficient condition of moral practical laws. That is, in order for a moral practical law to be applicable, there must be free will, and, if free will is present, then there will be a moral practical law that sets a standard for the free will. However, in Wells’s novel, the humanized beasts seem to lack free will. So, how can a law be applicable to them? By delving deeper into the mystery of Moreau’s strange island, I will shed light on the otherwise cumbersome concepts of free will, natural impulses, and practical laws, as well as their interrelationships. The upshot will be a deeper understanding of personhood through an exploration of the instinctual nature of animals, moral law, and free will.

about the author

At the time of publication, Dan Paul Dal Monte, is entering his fourth year in the doctoral program in philosophy at Temple University. His main interest is Kant’s theory of free will and its applicability to a modern context. He sees science fiction as an exciting medium for exploring philosophical ideas, and has written some of it himself.

Published: 2018-06-03

Issue: Vol 1 (2018): All Persons Great and Small: The Notion of Personhood in SF

Section: Yearly Theme

Copyright (c) 2018 Dan Paul Dal Monte

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.

Copyright for articles published in this journal is retained by the authors, with first publication rights granted to the journal. By submitting to this journal, you acknowledge that the work you submit has not been published before.

Articles and any other work submitted to this journal are published under an Attribution / Non-Commercial Creative Commons license; that is, by virtue of their appearance in this open access journal, articles are free to use – with proper attribution – in educational and other non-commercial settings.

There are no fees for authors publishing in the Journal.